Showing posts with label Scott Borden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scott Borden. Show all posts

Sunday, July 20, 2025

The Sixth Sunday after Pentecost, July 20, 2025

Holy Cross Monastery, West Park, NY
Br. Scott Wesley Borden

The Sixth Sunday after Pentecost, July 20, 2025


This morning, we meet Martha and Mary – two sisters who turn up in various Gospel stories along with their brother Lazarus. Or do they... Luke tells us about Mary and Martha. Luke doesn’t seem to know Br Lazarus... And Luke doesn’t mention the name of the town... Some scholars think it could be Bethany, home of Mary, Martha, and Lazarus from John’s Gospel, but others are certain that it cannot possibly be Bethany. So, we cannot be sure if these are the same Martha and Mary we meet in John’s Gospel. When we read scripture, other parts of scripture tend to whisper in our ears. We know this family. We know about Mary not only sitting attentively today, but anointing Jesus’ feet with Nard. We know about Jesus’ great love of their brother Lazarus and about Lazarus being raised from the dead. We may know these things, but Luke doesn’t and neither would the followers who first heard Luke’s telling of the Gospel. John’s Gospel, where we learn about Lazarus and nard and such, was still years in the future. To really meet Mary and Martha as they exist in this Gospel, in Luke’s world, we have to forget some of that stuff. When we’ve gotten John to be somewhat quiet, we might notice first that this Gospel story is not really about Mary and Martha, it's about Jesus. Jesus knocks at the door. The sisters let him in and prepare to feed this unannounced drop-in crowd. Well – Martha prepares to feed the crowd. Mary prepares to enjoy the benefits of Martha’s labor with her new best friends... We get an interesting glimpse into sisterly relationships. We can guess that Martha is the older sister because it seems to be her house. At the death of the parents, the oldest child would inherit both the estate and any younger siblings... So, Martha has had to run the household and put up with Mary for who knows how long. Mary flaking out from the work of hospitality seems to bug Martha. Hospitality was an important social obligation at that time. If folks showed up at your door, you were expected to feed them and house them... So, Martha is busy serving drinks and putting out plates of hors devours and such. Mary, on the other hand, seems like she would be happy opening a bag of chips and letting folks fend for themselves. Martha is not having it. But she doesn’t speak with her sister... she chooses instead to complain to Jesus. Of course, she has known her sister all her life and perhaps she knows it will do no good to correct her. All we know is that she is happy telling this stranger who has come to her door that her sister is useless. “Do you not care that she has left me to do all the work? Tell her to help me.” Of course, Martha’s complaints have additional benefits. She gets to vent. She also gets to make sure that the honored guest knows all the work is hers. Do you like the food, Jesus? I prepared that. Another drink, Jesus? I stomped the grapes myself. Mary didn’t help one little bit. I can’t say that Martha is making a good first impression on me. Martha knows that Jesus is important since she refers to him as “Lord.” Does she know more about Jesus? Does she know that he is the Son of God? Does she care? Luke is silent about Martha’s story – because this story is about Jesus, not Martha, not Mary. This story follows directly after the story of the Good Samaritan, which follows the story of the sending out of the Seventy and their happy return. There is a sort of travel theme to this tenth chapter of Luke. When the seventy (or seventy-two) disciples are sent, they are told to each go to the appointed village and lodge with some random family. Eat and drink what is offered. This is, in fact, just what Jesus is doing at the home of Martha and Mary. Jesus tells the disciples, when they are sent, not to worry. Eat what is offered. Drink what is offered. Don’t wander from house to house looking for a better buffet. And if you are not welcome, just move on. So, when Martha goes into high hospitality gear, Jesus has a reaction. She is surely worried that her hospitality will not be up to snuff. She no doubt takes pride in her house and in her food and drinks offerings. That slacker Mary is no help whatsoever. Jesus has told folks to just accept what is offered. But Martha is so busy putting on a show for Jesus that she is missing Jesus. Of course, I suspect that Jesus and the disciples are quite enjoying Martha’s handiwork. I don’t suppose that they are refusing the food and drink. But still, Martha can chill. She does not have to prove her worth to Jesus through her catering. This is a vital lesson for us – we do not have to prove our worth, we do not have to purchase Jesus’ love. Jesus already loves us... God already loves us. Just as God already loves Martha. Martha needs to learn this. This story reminds us that we are called to do what we can do – not less, and not more. It would be easy, hearing the story of the Good Samaritan earlier in this chapter of Luke, to think we must always measure up to that heroic level of sacrificing hospitality. That is what Martha seems to be aiming for. And Jesus tells her it's really not what he wants. Jesus tells us, in Matthew’s Gospel, that the yoke is easy, and the burden is light. In some sense, Martha and Mary are illustrating that for us. We would feel like we were better Christians if the yoke were heavier. For all of Martha’s complaining, I think she enjoys the yoke being a bit heavy. It makes her feel validated. But Jesus has different values. Jesus’ yoke is easy because Jesus wants it that way. Mary has chosen the lighter yoke. Mary has chosen the better part. Mary has chosen to be present to Jesus. It sounds like the choice we would all make, but the truth is we’re all drawn to sit in that pew with Martha. The reality is that Mary and Martha need each other. They complete each other. We need to be hospitable to our brothers and sisters and strangers and orphans and prisoners, and so on. If we’re not, then we have not listened to Jesus... not heard the Gospel. But attention to those in need does not replace worship of God. Nor does worship of God replace care for our brothers and sisters, God’s Children... for all of God’s creatures. I have often heard this Gospel passage presented as a sort of binary choice. We must choose to be like Martha or to be like Mary – choose wisely. But in a Mary-only world folks would go hungry while in a Martha-only world, Jesus and the Gospel would be shoved aside. Our choice is not Martha or Mary – our choice is both... Mary and Martha... in balance with each other. The great commandment for us is to love God and to love our neighbors as ourselves. And for each of us, this is a different exercise. Jesus sees us as individuals. Jesus calls to us where we are. In our modern world we often equate being busy with being good... valuable... important. The “Protestant Work Ethic” is part of our heritage. Or we quote the old truism that “idle hands are the devil’s workshop” - a notion that comes to us from Chaucer, not Jesus. Our modern world values activity over prayer. Yet you can’t look at the mess the world is in without recognizing that we need prayer, and we need it desperately. But we are badly out of balance on the Martha-Mary spectrum. Getting into balance does not involve going to the opposite end, just making little moves until balance is found. Our present secular world tells us that the Martha end of the spectrum is where we ought to be. But that is not a message from Jesus. Jesus loves us and wants nothing more that we should love him, love our fellow humans, and love God’s creation. Is there love in Martha’s heart? We don’t really know. If we listen to what she says about her sister, we can hear frustration and anger – lots of it. But love? I think the story is silent about that. Yet without love, as Paul would say, she is just a noisy cymbal. The work of discipleship is love. Anything done in love is discipleship. Anything done without love cannot be discipleship. It would be great if love were as simple as it tends to be in pop music... Easy to fall in love, to stay in love, to love forever... But popular music does not tell us the truth about love. The Letter to the Corinthians tells a more substantial story of love: Love is patient; love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast; it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres. This story of Mary and Martha seems to me to embody the great command. Mary shows us the love of God and Martha shows us the love of neighbor. Our task is to unite them.

Thursday, May 29, 2025

The Ascension, May 29, 2025

Holy Cross Monastery, West Park, NY

Br. Scott Wesley Borden

The Feast of the Ascension, May 29, 2025


It's been about five months since we welcomed Jesus into the fully human life on this earth. Now we are on the other side of that event, seeing Jesus off at the ascension. We have Luke, primarily, both in the Gospel and in the Acts of the Apostles to thank for this 

We don’t see Jesus in the flesh after this. Jesus has assured us that if he goes, then he will send the Holy Spirit for the next part of the journey. So, let's talk about what this may mean...But first, let's talk about the number forty 

This number turns up in scripture fairly frequently. Forty days in the wilderness for Jesus after baptism... forty years in the wilderness for the people of Israel after they escape Egypt... forty days and nights of rain for Noah... And hiding behind the scenes in today’s feast is the number forty... Jesus rises on Easter and Ascends on this day, forty days later. 

It’s clear that forty is symbolic. It's just not so clear what it symbolizes. Forty was thought of as a number for reflection and change of heart – hence forty days in the desert for Jesus and forty days of Lent (exclusive of Sundays and feast days) for us 

It was an appropriate number for punishment – if you were administering lashes, forty was the maximum number permitted in Jewish law. Often, we hear of someone condemned to forty lashes minus one – for example Paul received this punishment on a number of occasions. One lash was withheld as a little insurance policy for those administering the punishment. If you miscounted your lashes, you still might not have broken God’s law... 

Forty figured into pregnancy in two ways. It was thought to take forty days for the “seed” to take root in the womb (this was a pre-medical view of pregnancy) and forty weeks for the child to be formed and ready for birth. These days we think of thirty-nine as the number of weeks in a pregnancy but forty was the number used in Biblical times. Pregnancy hasn’t changed, but we start counting at a different point... And the notion of a seed taking root in the womb has gone completely. 

We heard most of what Luke had to say about the Ascension in this morning’s readings.  

Matthew hints at the Ascension, but just in passing on the way to the “Great Commission”. Matthew wants us to get down to the business of evangelism... of sharing the good news.  

Luke is a little more patient; we are allowed to stand in awe looking up at the sky in wonder for a short time even to worship – though Luke certainly calls us to share the Gospel as well. 

Luke foreshadows the Ascension. In the twentieth chapter of the Luke’s Gospel Jesus says to Mary Magdalene: “Do not cling to me, because I have not yet ascended. But go to my brothers and say to them, ‘I am ascending to my God and your God.’” Luke is so concerned about the Ascension that he must tell us it is coming and then tell the story in both the Gospel and Acts. 

As written, this is the story of Jesus literally being lifted up from the earth, through the clouds, to the right hand of God in heaven. This assumes an understanding of the universe in three tiers – the underworld, the world, and the heavens. The blue of our sky was understood to be the blue jewels that made up the floor of heaven – lapis lazuli 

Within a century or so of the Ascension, some theologians were already concerned that the “three-tiered universe” was out of date. Origen, for example, seems to have found it an embarrassment. By his time, the universe was no longer understood to be a three-tiered confection 

But here we are, on Ascension Day, a day that is built on the notion of Jesus being lifted up from tier two to tier three as a crowd watches. Do we suspend our scientific knowledge to accept the literal nature of this event? Do we swallow hard and cross our fingers as Origin might have done 

Our Brother Andrew, of blessed memory, had a fond saying. Being a good Scotsman, he loved all things Celtic. He would begin a fantastical Celtic story with a disclaimer: “It may not have happened exactly this way, but this is the truth.” Certainly, not all truth is literal. 

In truth, all mythology is based on truth that is not literal. Our modern society is greatly impoverished because we want to understand anything that is not literal truth as a falsehood. We use “myth” and “lie pretty much interchangeably. But myth and lie are not synonyms. As Br Andrew would remind us, it may not have happened exactly like this, but this is the truth. 

Jesus is not the first person to be Assumed bodily. Enoch and Elijah were both Assumed. Some of the leaders of the Roman State were assumed to be Assumed. The Greeks believed that Apollonius was Assumed. And not too long ago the Roman Church determined officially that Mary, Mother of Jesus, was Assumed.  

In the Zoroastrian tradition, the Hindu tradition, and Islamic tradition there is a belief that certain important leaders were Assumed. 

So, nudged on by Br Andrew, I ask myself, what might the truth of Jesus’ Ascension be? 

Charles King, in his book “Every Valley”, looks at how Georg Friedrich Handle created his great masterpiece “Messiah. He describes Handle’s process as “the working out in music of a purposeful, systematic, and moral imagination of things you can’t yet see.” Handle’s purpose was not to create a pleasing setting for certain passages of scripture, but to create a space for our moral imaginations to work. Could this be Luke’s purpose as well? 

Luke gives few answers about the Ascension. Did Jesus float – or was there some mechanism of lifting? What happened at twenty-six thousand feet, when the atmosphere was no longer breathable? But I have to stop myself and remember the wisdom of Br Andrew. And to allow Handel to whisper in my ear to use my moral imagination. 

The Assumption of Jesus suggests an intimacy with God in Heaven that is unique. I have an expectation of Heaven after I die – I’m just not at all sure what I expect... who or what I will be in that context, or even what that context will be. Jesus, we trust, knew more... knows more. And we don’t know what Jesus knows...  

We believe that our broken human nature is transformed in heaven – that strife and greed will be in us no more, that pain and sorrow will be ours no more, that as Isaiah saw, the wolf and the lamb can lie down together; that as Martin Luther King dreamed, all of God’s children can play together without hurting each other. My literal imagination can do little with these images. But my moral imagination can do much. 

There is a reason for using all our imaginative abilities, moral, literal, artistic, and so forth to see, in our mind’s eye, heaven. Heaven may not be like what we see, but that doesn't mean it's not true. 

I am reminded of the words of Father Daniel Berrigan, Roman Catholic Priest and powerful voice against the Vietnam war. I had the chance to hear him speak across the river at Bard College. A student asked him, given his vision of what the world could be, how he could live in the world the way it is.  

Fr Berigan answered that he lived in a community, a Jesuit community, that while far from perfect still managed now and then to give glimpses of what heaven could be. And it was that vision that made it possible to live in our very imperfect world. He had a moral imagination that allowed him to see glimpses of heaven.  

When the Disciples are pestering Jesus to tell them about heaven his answer is – don't worry about heaven... it’s a very big place. Worry about here and now.  

When the Sadducees are trying to trick Jesus with a question about how marriage works in heaven, Jesus replies that marriage as we understand it is not a thing in heaven.  

Jesus seems to be assuring them that they (and we) don’t need to have a moral imagination of heaven. We need to have a moral imagination, a moral vision, of this world, of Earth. 

Just before he goes, Jesus tells the disciples to be clothed with power from on high; and after that, to share the good news of salvation with all the world. This power from on high sounds a bit mysterious, perhaps even threatening. But it is a reference to the Holy Spirit – the third person of the trinity. Jesus has been hinting about this Holy Spirit, the Advocate, the Comforter, for some time. And Jesus has made clear that when he goes, then the Holy Spirit will come. This is that moment. 

I don’t have a need for this story to be literally true. I do have a need to ignore, or at least discount, that part of my mind that wants to argue with the literal details. When we force things to adhere to our literal understanding, we limit them to what our minds can understand. 

Perhaps the most curious thing for me about the Ascension is the urgent warning Jesus gives to Mary – do not cling to me... I hear Jesus telling Mary not to hold on too tightly to the Jesus she has known, the earthly, human literal Jesus. Doing so will inhibit her ability to welcome the Holy Spirit. And, frankly, the Jesus she will come to know is much greater than the Jesus she has known. This is the Jesus we come to know as well, if we don’t hold too tightly to what we think we know. 

The person of Jesus in flesh and blood is relatable, even loveable. The amorphous holy spirit is much harder to get our arms around – literally and figuratively... 

But we must let go of our images of Jesus so that we can open ourselves to the Holy Spirit who dwells in us and around us. It is faith that leads us toward this unknown region.  

And this unknown region is nothing less than the land where Martin Luther King observed all of God’s children playing together... where Isaiah watched lambs lie down with lions... where John of Patmos could see twelve city gates – three in every direction... Gates that are open all day and there is no night.  

It is nothing less than the Kingdom of God. It is nothing less than our home.